Next Story
Newszop

'Tired script': Election Commission slams Rahul Gandhi's 'vote theft' claim; cites 2018 Kamal Nath case

Send Push
NEW DELHI: The Election Commission (EC) on Friday came down heavily on Congress leader Rahul Gandhi over his allegations of large-scale voter fraud, accusing him of repeating an old political “script” and challenging him to either formally verify his claims or apologise to the nation.

In a statement, the poll body claimed the Leader of Opposition in the Lok Sabha had raised “baseless” charges similar to those made in 2018 by then Madhya Pradesh Congress chief Kamal Nath , which were dismissed by the Supreme Court.

'Rahul Gandhi repeated a tired script': EC
“At his recent press conference, Rahul repeated a tired script. In 2018, it was then Kamal Nath, the then President of MPCC; today, it’s the leader of opposition in Lok Sabha playing the same tune,” the EC said.

According to the EC, in 2018, Congress leaders attempted to mislead the court by producing documents from a private website to claim errors in electoral rolls, including instances where “the same face was shown again for as many as 36 voters.”


The EC said those defects had been rectified months earlier and the details shared with the party. “The Court refused to accept the prayer of Kamal Nath. Now, in 2025, they, being aware that the same trick cannot be played in court, are trying to mislead the people by claiming irregularities in the electoral rolls,” it added.

'Opposition leader tried to sensationalise issue': EC
The Commission also cited a specific case involving the name of Aditya Srivastava, which Rahul claimed appeared in three different states. “In fact, [this] was rectified months ago,” it said. It further reminded the Congress leader that the Kamal Nath judgment had “settled” the position on machine-readable electoral rolls, and accused him of disregarding the Supreme Court’s decisions.

“Law provides a specific procedure for both making objections to the roll and for making an appeal. Instead of availing the legal processes, he tried to sensationalise the issue by making baseless claims in the media,” the statement said.

“If Rahul believes in his analysis and believes that his allegations against the EC are true, he should have respect for the law and sign the Declaration, or apologise to the nation for raising absurd allegations against the EC.”

EC vs Rahul Gandhi
The standoff follows letters from the chief electoral officers (CEOs) of Karnataka, Maharashtra, and Haryana asking Rahul to submit the names of voters he believes were wrongly included or removed, along with a signed oath under Rule 20(3)(b) of the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960.

The Karnataka CEO reminded him that rolls are prepared transparently under the Representation of the People Act, while Maharashtra and Haryana officials noted that Congress had not filed any formal appeals over alleged discrepancies.

On Thursday, Rahul alleged “vote chori” in a Karnataka constituency involving 1,00,250 votes and irregularities in the rolls.

Dismissing the Commission’s demand for a signed declaration, he said: “I am a politician; what I say to the people is my word. I am saying it to the people publicly, take it as an oath. Interestingly, they haven’t denied the information.” He accused the EC of colluding with the BJP to “undermine democracy” and warned polling officials allegedly involved of consequences if the Opposition came to power.

He also claimed that the EC was “destroying evidence” by limiting the preservation of CCTV and webcasting footage to 45 days unless election results were legally challenged. “It is the 21st century; you can keep as much data as you want in a hard drive, even 10 years old data, but the Election Commission wants to destroy the CCTV footage in 45 days,” he said.

The poll body earlier said Rahul had failed to respond to its June 12 letter inviting him to substantiate earlier claims of “rigging” in the Maharashtra Assembly elections. “Why? Is it because his media statements were baseless?” EC sources told PTI.

Rahul has warned that such alleged irregularities could be repeated in the upcoming Bihar elections .
Loving Newspoint? Download the app now